Compare

Aster Mail vs Disroot Email

Aster Mail and Disroot Email are privacy-focused email services with free options. Aster adds encrypted storage, native apps and paid plans; Disroot offers a free mailbox with webmail and standard email-client access.

Compare them if you need to keep costs low, connect email to existing apps, choose between stronger built-in encryption and optional encryption, or use a custom domain.

Round by round

  1. PricingDisroot Email wins

    Disroot Email is free for its basic mailbox, while Aster Mail has a free plan plus paid plans from $2.42 per user per month when billed annually. Disroot can charge for extras: additional mailbox storage is listed at €0.15 per gigabyte per month, and custom-domain linking is a lifetime feature tied to a user-decided donation. Aster’s paid plans add larger encrypted storage, more aliases and domains, and additional rules. Choose Disroot when a no-cost mailbox is the main requirement. Aster wins only if you are willing to pay for higher included limits and want a clearly listed subscription ladder.

  2. Free plan limitsAster Mail wins

    Aster’s free plan includes 10 GB of encrypted storage, five email aliases, one custom domain, end-to-end encryption, Aster Bridge access, two mail rules and attachments up to 25 MB. It has no trial requirement and needs no credit card. Disroot’s free mailbox includes 1 GB of storage, webmail, IMAP, SMTP, SMTPS and POP access, plus optional PGP encryption through Mailvelope; attachments can be up to 64 MB. Aster provides much more mailbox space and more included account features. Disroot has the larger attachment limit, but Aster wins the overall free-plan comparison.

  3. Email featuresAster Mail wins

    Aster Mail automatically encrypts mail between Aster accounts and uses hybrid post-quantum encryption for those messages. Its plans include aliases, custom domains and mail rules, with higher limits on paid tiers. Disroot Email uses Roundcube webmail with threaded messages, folders, filters, drag-and-drop handling, attachment previews and support for more than 80 interface languages. Disroot also supports plus addressing, catch-all custom domains and optional PGP through Mailvelope, but messages are stored unencrypted on its servers unless users encrypt them. Aster wins for built-in account-to-account encryption and broader included limits; Disroot offers useful webmail organization tools.

  4. Setup and daily useDisroot Email wins

    Disroot Email works through browser webmail or common desktop and mobile mail clients. Its documentation lists setup help and gives direct IMAP, SMTP, SMTPS and POP settings, so users can connect established apps using standard protocols. Aster Mail offers web, desktop and mobile access, plus native Windows, Mac and Linux apps. Its Bridge connects desktop IMAP and SMTP apps, while iOS is currently a TestFlight beta. Aster also provides QuickSwitch for importing mail from Gmail, Outlook, Yahoo, Proton and other IMAP providers. Disroot wins for straightforward standard-client setup; Aster is stronger for migration and native desktop software.

  5. Mail app connectionsEven

    Aster Bridge supports desktop IMAP and SMTP mail apps, and QuickSwitch can import mail from Gmail, Outlook, Yahoo, Proton and other IMAP providers. Aster also offers one-click mailbox export in MBOX format on every plan. Disroot supports IMAP, SMTP, SMTPS and POP and lists Thunderbird, Evolution, KMail, Claws Mail, Mailpile, K-9 Mail, FairEmail and Apple Mail as usable clients. Both can connect with existing email software, but they do so differently: Aster adds migration and export tools, while Disroot lists more established protocol-based client choices. The facts do not establish a clear overall winner.

  6. Supported platformsDisroot Email wins

    Aster Mail supports web, Windows, Mac and Linux desktop apps, Android, and an iOS beta distributed through TestFlight. Disroot Email supports web, Android, iOS, Linux, macOS and Windows, and also lists a browser extension. Both cover the major desktop and mobile systems. Disroot lists iOS among its supported platforms and adds an extension, while Aster specifically identifies its iOS support as beta. On the stated platform coverage, Disroot offers the broader and less limited set, so it wins this dimension.

  7. Privacy and encryptionAster Mail wins

    Aster Mail says email between Aster accounts is end-to-end encrypted automatically, with hybrid post-quantum encryption, and that its service is hosted in Germany under EU privacy law. It also says there are no inbox ads, scanning or AI. Disroot requires SSL/TLS for available connections and says its servers use disk encryption, but ordinary email remains readable on the server unless users apply GnuPG or PGP. Disroot retains operational logs normally for no longer than 48 hours, with some login IPs kept while a device is logged in. Aster wins for stronger built-in message protection and no-inbox-scanning policy.

  8. Public APIEven

    Disroot's product pages do not describe a public email REST API or software development kit. Aster documents Bridge for desktop IMAP and SMTP mail apps, along with import and MBOX export tools, but those are mail connections and data-transfer features rather than a public programming interface. Disroot documents webmail and the standard IMAP, SMTP, SMTPS and POP protocols. Neither receives an edge on the listed developer-facing capabilities.

The facts side by side

  • Free tier · from $2.42/moPriceFree tier
  • —Public API—
  • YesOpen sourceYes
  • YesFree tierYes
  • —Free trialNo
  • ✓Web✓
  • ✓Windows✓
  • ✓Mac✓
  • ✓Linux✓
  • ✓iOS✓
  • ✓Android✓
  • ✓Free plan✓
  • —Encryption scope—
  • —Custom domains—
  • —IMAP support—
  • —Private calendar—
  • —Legal jurisdiction—
  • #2Standing on Private Email Services#1
  • Pick Aster Mail if
  • You want more free storage, built-in encryption and aliases.
  • You need migration tools, mailbox export or native desktop apps.
  • You want paid plans with larger storage and domain limits.
  • Pick Disroot Email if
  • You need a completely free basic mailbox.
  • You prefer standard IMAP, SMTP and POP setup.
  • You want broad client support, full iOS listing or a browser extension.

By what you need

  • Aster MailLargest free mailbox. Aster includes 10 GB of encrypted free storage, compared with Disroot’s 1 GB mailbox.
  • Disroot EmailFree basic email. Disroot provides a free mailbox and standard mail protocols without a paid subscription.
  • Aster MailBuilt-in message encryption. Aster automatically encrypts mail between Aster accounts; Disroot requires user-applied PGP or GnuPG for stored-message encryption.
  • Disroot EmailStandard mail clients. Disroot directly lists IMAP, SMTP, SMTPS and POP settings plus many compatible clients.
  • Aster MailMigration and export. Aster offers QuickSwitch imports and free one-click MBOX export on every plan.

Verdict. Aster Mail is the stronger choice for a larger free mailbox, automatic encryption between its accounts, migration tools and native desktop apps. Its free plan includes 10 GB, five aliases and one custom domain, with paid plans for more capacity. Disroot Email suits people who want a free 1 GB mailbox that works with standard IMAP, SMTP and POP clients, plus broad listed client support and a full iOS listing. Disroot offers optional PGP and custom-domain linking through a donation, but ordinary stored mail is unencrypted unless users protect it themselves.

Questions

Which service gives more free storage?

Aster Mail’s free plan includes 10 GB of encrypted storage. Disroot Email’s free mailbox includes 1 GB.

Do both support custom domains?

Yes. Aster’s free plan includes one custom domain. Disroot offers custom-domain linking as a lifetime feature tied to a user-decided donation.

Is end-to-end encryption automatic?

Aster automatically encrypts mail between Aster accounts. Disroot does not provide end-to-end encryption by default; users can add PGP with Mailvelope.

Can I use normal email apps?

Yes. Aster supports desktop IMAP and SMTP apps through Aster Bridge. Disroot provides IMAP, SMTP, SMTPS and POP settings.

Which one has an iOS app?

Both list iOS support. Aster identifies its iOS app as a TestFlight beta, while Disroot lists iOS among its supported platforms.